Why does Scotland use a Conditional Offer instead of a fixed penalty notice?

Scotland's criminal procedure has always been distinct from England. The Conditional Offer of Fixed Penalty is the Scottish equivalent of an English fixed penalty notice and is governed by the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 as well as the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988. The substantive offence is the same across Great Britain, but the prosecution route runs through the Procurator Fiscal rather than the local police force. If you accept the Conditional Offer, you pay £100 and accept 3 points. If you reject, the case is referred to the Procurator Fiscal.

Where would a contested A90 case be heard?

Contested A90 cases are heard at the Justice of the Peace Court covering the location of the alleged offence, typically Aberdeen or Forfar for the Dundee-Stonehaven corridor. The Justice of the Peace Court is a lay tribunal sitting with a legally qualified clerk. Appeals against conviction or sentence go to the Sheriff Appeal Court and ultimately the High Court of Justiciary on points of law. The Procurator Fiscal prosecutes on behalf of the Lord Advocate; Police Scotland does not appear in court directly.

Will points from an A90 fine show on my English licence?

Yes. The Great Britain driving licence is a single document and points are added by reference to the offence date regardless of which jurisdiction issued the NIP. An SP30 endorsement for 3 points lasts 4 years from the offence date, with the points active for the first 3 years. Insurers will see the endorsement in the same way as an English-issued one. If you are an English licence-holder caught on the A90, the procedure differs but the licence consequences are identical.

How tight is the A90 average-speed tolerance?

Police Scotland follows the NPCC speed enforcement guidelines, recommending prosecution where the recorded speed exceeds the limit by more than 10 percent plus 2 mph. So on a 70 mph section, the typical threshold is 79 mph. The threshold is policy, not law, and any speed over the limit is technically prosecutable. Average-speed enforcement is unforgiving because it measures mean speed between camera pairs, so a sustained marginal excess will trigger even if you never had a hard burst over the threshold.

Can I plead guilty by post and avoid attending court?

Yes. The Procurator Fiscal's complaint will give you the option to plead guilty by post or to attend a pleading diet. A guilty plea by post avoids the inconvenience of attending but you waive your chance to advance mitigation in person. If you want to challenge the substantive evidence (camera Type Approval, signage, etc.), you must plead not guilty and attend a trial diet at the Justice of the Peace Court. You can be represented by a solicitor or appear as a party litigant.

What if I was not on the A90 at the time?

If your vehicle's registered keeper details have been used but your vehicle was not in fact on the A90 at the time, this could be a cloned plate or an ANPR misread. Gather corroborating evidence: dashcam footage, fuel and toll receipts elsewhere, work logbook entries, telematics or tracker data, and witnesses. Send these with your s.172 response and notify Police Scotland that you suspect plate cloning. They will request the camera image so they can compare the make, model and colour to your vehicle. If the images do not match, the case will be withdrawn.

A90 Average Speed Fine Appeal (Scotland) | AppealAFine

The A90 runs from Edinburgh to Fraserburgh and has long average-speed enforcement sections, particularly between Dundee and Stonehaven and at known accident clusters such as Laurencekirk. The Aberdeen-Dundee average-speed scheme was introduced in 2017 by the A90 Safety Group and Transport Scotland, and the system has been credited with significant casualty reductions. Enforcement is by Police Scotland, with prosecutions referred to the Procurator Fiscal and any contested cases heard in the Justice of the Peace Court. The substantive offence is the same as in the rest of Great Britain (section 89 Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984, with section 1 Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 for the 14-day NIP rule and section 172 Road Traffic Act 1988 for driver identification), but the procedure is Scottish. You receive a Conditional Offer of Fixed Penalty rather than an English-style FPN and you respond within 28 days.

Grounds that work for A90 speeding fines

NIP not served within 14 days

Section 1 of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 applies in Scotland and requires the Notice of Intended Prosecution to reach the registered keeper within 14 days of the offence. Service to the DVLA address is good service even if you have moved, so keep DVLA records up to date. If the NIP is dated more than 14 days after the offence and your address is correct, the prosecution is barred. Write to Police Scotland's Camera Safety Unit citing section 1 RTOA 1988 and ask for the Conditional Offer to be withdrawn. If they refuse and the case goes to the Justice of the Peace Court, raise the time limit as your first issue.

Average-speed Type Approval and calibration

The A90 average-speed cameras must be Type Approved under section 20 of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 and calibrated to the manufacturer's certified interval. When you reject the Conditional Offer, ask the Camera Safety Unit for the Type Approval Certificate and the calibration certificate covering the date and time of the alleged offence. If either is missing, expired or not specific to the camera pair that detected your vehicle, the evidence may be inadmissible. The Procurator Fiscal will often withdraw a prosecution rather than risk a not-proven verdict on technical evidence issues.

Signage and limit changes through the corridor

The A90 between Dundee and Stonehaven includes 70 mph dual carriageway sections and 60 mph single-carriageway transitions, with local 40 and 50 mph reductions at junctions. The Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2016 require correct repeater signs at appropriate spacing. If your alleged offence relates to a transition section where signage may have been ambiguous, request the signage diagrams from Transport Scotland and Police Scotland for the date of offence. The Justice of the Peace Court will dismiss where the lower limit was not properly displayed for the relevant section.

Driver identification on shared or company vehicles

If the vehicle was driven by more than one person, section 172(4) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 allows a defence of reasonable diligence. Document the steps you have taken to identify the driver: work rota, family calendar, telematics or tracker data, fuel card transactions. The defence is narrow and you must prove the diligence; it is not enough simply to say you do not remember. If you genuinely cannot identify the driver, state that with supporting evidence in the s.172 response and prepare to argue the diligence point at the Justice of the Peace Court if challenged.

Marginal speed and mitigation for course or fine reduction

Police Scotland follows the NPCC speed enforcement guidance, with a tolerance of 10 percent plus 2 mph before prosecution. If your recorded speed is within the tolerance, raise that in your response. Even if not, a marginal excess speed with a clean licence is good mitigation. Speed awareness courses are offered in Scotland through the National Driver Offender Retraining Scheme partner; eligibility is the same as in England. Otherwise, the Justice of the Peace Court applies fines and points by reference to speed bands similar to the English Magistrates' Court Sentencing Guidelines.

Got a A90 speeding fine?

Our tool checks your specific notice details and tells you in 60 seconds whether you have grounds to appeal.

Check my fine free

Local detail: A90

The Aberdeen-Dundee A90 average-speed scheme launched in 2017, covering 50 miles between the cities.
Police Scotland's Camera Safety Unit operates the enforcement system.
Casualty data from Transport Scotland shows significant reductions in fatal and serious collisions since 2017.
Local accident clusters at Laurencekirk and Stonehaven have had additional fixed cameras since.
Limit transitions include 70 mph dual carriageway, 60 mph single carriageway, and 40 or 50 mph at junctions.
Prosecutions are referred to the Procurator Fiscal at Aberdeen or Dundee Sheriffdom depending on offence location.
Speed awareness courses are administered by Police Scotland through their NDORS partner.

Got a speeding fine in A90?

How to appeal an A90 average-speed speeding fine

Quick facts